Lifeboar Ethics Essays - Population, Demographic Economics

Lifeboar Ethics Garrett Hardin's argument for the preservation of well-to-do societies is embodied by his extended metaphor of each society as a lifeboat with its members the lifeboat's occupants. His presentation of this metaphor is key in his assertions that the creation of an international food bank, efforts to improve agriculture in foreign nations (the Green Revolution), and lax immigration laws will all result in universal tragedy. Hardin's initial complaint is against humanitarian efforts to establish an international food bank, to which rich nations will contribute and from which poor nations will draw. Theoretically, accidents (famine, crop failure, etc.) should teach nations to plan ahead and budget for future tragedies; the existence of an international food bank would inhibit this process from occurring by spoiling the benefiting nations. In addition, a food bank would allow population to constantly balloon regardless of immediate food availability. For example, a famine should reduce a society's population back to its carrying capacity, but an international food bank would prevent this regression. A popularly proposed alternative is the Green Revolution, where agriculture is improved within a nation rather than food delivered directly to it. Despite the superior logic inherent in this idea as compared to that of a food bank, both have the exact same result: overpopulation. Hardin proceeds to point out that immigration itself represents a significant portion of this problem. Ethnic groups maintain paranoia of the label ethnocentricity, and Hardin insists that this prevents wealthy nations from creating more selective immigration laws. The consequence is the same as that of the food bank: a drain on the wealthy nations. Essentially Hardin asserts that food banks would prevent poor countries from learning their lesson and ultimately destroy the benefiting nation due to uncontrolled population growth. Likewise, the Green Revolution also spurs on this disastrous uncontrolled population growth. Finally, uncontrolled immigration allows foreigners to go to the food rather than vice-versa, thus destroying the wealthy nations in the same manner that food banks would destroy the poor. Quite simply, I disagree with Garrett Hardin's theories regarding the self-preservation of wealthy nations in his paper Lifeboat Ethics. His assertions regarding the nations' limited carrying capacities adheres the idea of self-preservation idea to firm logic, but logic cannot overpower the humanitarian impulse of mankind. World food banks and the Green Revolution are used to demonstrate the ratchet effect; a firm yet ineffectual point asserting that the efforts of wealthy nations to aid the poor are inhibiting to the welfare of the environment. Obviously this effect makes an excellent graphic for a thesis page and is alarming in many respects, but essentially it is encouragement for the wealthy populace to abandon the poor to the consequences of famine. Hardin's initial analysis maintains that each nation can be viewed as a lifeboat in an ocean, each with a limited amount of space. As symptoms of overpopulation develop within a nation, members of that nation begin to fall overboard and seek refuge on other lifeboats. Similarly, overcrowded or poor nations who cannot support their population turn to the wealthier nations for food, money, and immigration opportunities; very similar to those adrift seeking passage on another lifeboat. This abstract view is actually well thought-out and consistent with parallels in the real world today, but simultaneously uncomfortable for most people. For example, this analogy may be extended to say that people aren't willing to watch others die in the ocean while they are safe in a lifeboat, nor will they willingly watch others die on the planet while they possess the capability of saving them. This logical yet flawed model continues as Hardin reflects on the effects of taking on additional passengers, just as modern nations help those in need. According to Hardin, several problems arise when deciding to help those less fortunate: too many people will swamp the lifeboat (a.k.a.- the nation), no method exists to fairly choose which people to save, and if no saving actions are made, modern ethics will result in the guilt of the survivors. Again, this analysis is very consistent with the real world, as every day we (as individuals and as a nation) are confronted with opportunities to help those less fortunate. It is inconsistent, however, in that these daily confrontations do not

How to Write a Better Essay - A Sample Of a Writing Assignment

How to Write a Better Essay - A Sample Of a Writing AssignmentThe key to a successful writing assignment is a sample of a writing assignment. A sample of a writing assignment gives the writer a blueprint on how to write a better essay. This is how you make your college essays better and faster.A sample of a writing assignment will have some part of the essay in it. You can include the reading list, the introduction, or the body as well. Keep these parts separate from the essay.A sample of a writing assignment has more than just the words written on it. A sample will have other sections where you can actually show how to write a better essay. These sections are definitely more important than the parts of the essay where you actually are putting the words down. You cannot take an entire essay and be able to rewrite it.Make sure that each of the different sections has a list of points to be made. You can include questions, answer key, and even examples in them. This will help you write a better essay that will be able to hold the attention of your reader for a longer period of time. You will also be able to quickly get through an entire essay without the reader from getting bored.These lists can include research, examples, reading, and any other items that you would like to include. Make sure that all of these are separated from the essay itself. They are important because they keep the reader from having a headache. They will be able to focus on one point at a time and not constantly be distracted by a whole lot of stuff. The more detailed the writing the better.There are many places where you can find samples of writing assignments. They can be found online or at colleges. Find one that fits your style of writing. If you are a writer who likes to have a specific theme then go with a sample of a writing assignment that reflects that theme. If you have a typical college student, then make sure that you find a sample that reflects that too.If you are looking for a sample of a writing assignment then this is the place to look. You will want to use it to find the style that works best for you. This can be a helpful tool for everyone to use. Remember that writing an essay does not have to be boring.